Melinda Tankard-Reist is not the internet nor sex police
Monday January 16th 2012, 9:39 am

Unsatisfied that she’s completely unable to police Australians’ sexual behaviours, sex-hating anti-porn activist Melinda Tankard-Reist has paid her local Dennis Denuto to send a threatening letter to the No Place For Sheep blog, shaking her rattle & wailing that if NPfS doesn’t delete all posts about MTR, she’ll sue for defamation:

MTR threatens Sheep with legal action if we don’t censor our posts about her immediately
Posted: January 14, 2012

Just got home to find a letter from the lawyers of Melinda Tankard Reist demanding I withdraw all my posts about her or very bad things will ensue.

This is pretty amusing when you read some of the things MTR writes about those she does not approve of.

She’s going to have to sue a few more blogs than just mine, because I’m not the only one who’s written that she’s a Baptist, and attends Belconnen Baptist Church. It’s well in the public domain.

And how bizarre it is that someone who is a devout Christian is so cagey about her faith and her practice? Why not be open about her religious faith? Christians usually are. What does she have to hide?

At least I know now why Rachel Hills didn’t ask those questions, or if she asked the questions, didn’t publish any answers!

“Write about my religious beliefs and I’ll sue you!” Now that’s novel.

If you want to see just how cagey MTR is about this watch this interview with ABC TV’s Jane Hutcheon when Hutcheon asks about her religion and how it affects her work. She tries to follow Jesus, she says, but she doesn’t want anybody focusing on her religion because that will distract from her work.

Well, we might all be about to find out just exactly what MTR’s religious faith is, because she’s going to have to come clean if she wants to sue me.

Just when you think things can’t get any more bizarre…

Apparently MTR is upset that she’s been identified as a member of a Baptist church congregation (which is, admittedly, somewhat embarrassing). MTR has admitted in an interview on the ABC that she’s in fact a Christian. So, what’s the problem? Nothing as far as I can tell, beyond the fact that VERY public figure MTR is unable to control criticisms of her.

MTR is about to learn some very hard lessons:

    1. You cannot control the private sexual behaviours of the population at large

    2. You cannot control speech on the internet, even that critical of you

    3. Bullying with impotent legal threats will attract the ire of tens of thousands of internet users

    4. Bullying to suppress speech will invoke the ‘I am Spartacus‘ effect, where many thousands of internet users will repeat the message one is trying to suppress, in solidarity against the bully

    5. Repetition of the speech one is trying to suppress is known as the Streisand Effect, where many, many more people will become aware of the speech you are trying to suppress than would have been aware of it if you had not tried to bully your critics into silence

I have offered NPfS space on mgk for the purpose of mirroring their posts about MTR and any threatening lawyeresque letters related to the same, fulfilling the ‘I am Spartacus’ and ‘Streisand’ effects.

You want to try to bully me into silence, Melinda? Have a go. Ain’t my first fuckin’ day at the rodeo- and I’m not afraid of you or your conveyancer.


UPDATE: The Age has done a bit:

Tankard Reist – who briefed lawyers to warn off liberal blogger Jennifer Wilson – says it’s not being called Christian she objects to, but the claim that she is ”deceptive and duplicitous about her religious beliefs”.

3 Comments so far
Leave a comment

I have also offered No Place For Sheep space on my blog, Frog Ponds Rock.

“I am Spartacus”

Also I can’t stand a bully.

Comment by frogpondsrock 01.16.12 @ 10:23 am

She’s just upset she can’t force her puritanical “christian” beliefs on the entire population. Ask her to prove that her God exists, scientifically. She can’t do it – no-one can !!

She’s a bully and a hypocrite – she spoke at my kids’ school a few months ago and I walked out in disgust when I asked her a question about her faith and she COULD NOT ANSWER ME !

Comment by moldor 03.19.12 @ 2:04 pm

From the moderation queue:

Author : Imwithher (IP: ,
E-mail :
Whois :
I’m with her. It takes guts to stand up and say it, but having lived enough of my years to know better, the ubiquity and variety of today’s internet porn (and the way it’s accesible to kids) makes it more trouble than it’s worth. If skeptical, check out yourbrainonporn and be sure.

Why yes, it takes guts to leave a ridiculous comment with a gutsy anonymous username. Commenter is so over-the-top gutsy that s/he felt moved to use Tor to access mgk to avoid being identified.

You go, old gutsy! xD

And yes, ‘yourbrainonporn’ is complete pseudoscientific rubbish. Simple christian propaganda.

Comment by weez 03.25.12 @ 6:56 am

Leave a comment